Discus CS overtakes paraglider on ridge; mid-air collision

Münster, Switzerland Schempp-Hirth Discus CS

Two pilots were fatally injured when a Discus CS and an Advance Sigma 7 paraglider collided in mid-air near the Galmihornhütte; glider destroyed, paraglider damaged. Weak thermals had concentrated soaring traffic in a narrow area above Münster airfield. After working figure-eights on the slope, the glider overtook the paraglider on its left at ~3× its speed, then turned right back across its path. The right wing struck the paraglider lines at ~140 m AGL. The glider yawed into a spinning descent; the partially collapsed paraglider settled with its pilot likely unconscious. Probable cause: overtaking turn with loss of visual contact.

  1. Ridge soaring, dense traffic: The glider pilot launched by aerotow from RWY 05 at Münster and released at ~2 780 m MSL near the Risihorn. Returning to the Galmihornhütte ridge ~2 km NW of the airfield, he flew figure-eights at ~2 400 m MSL on the slope without gaining altitude for about 54 minutes. Weak thermal conditions had kept most local soaring within a short radius of the airfield; at the time of the collision around 18 other aircraft were within 10 minutes of the glider, with 10 of them within ~250 m vertically.
  2. Mixed glider + paraglider area: Weak thermals had concentrated gliders and paragliders into the same small ridge area. A published exception to the 5 km hang-glider exclusion zone allowed paragliders to transit the airfield area in summer. The pre-flight briefing did not cover paraglider mixing, as an unusual concentration was not anticipated after the championship the previous week.
  3. Paraglider climbs to glider level: The paraglider, having launched earlier from the Fiescheralp and worked thermals along the route, arrived at the Galmihornhütte at ~2 200 m MSL and climbed in a thermal for three minutes, gaining ~135 m. It then continued straight north-east, slightly above the glider, which was still working figure-eights on the slope.
  4. Overtake on left at ~3× speed: The glider passed the paraglider on its left, with the slope to its own left, on a heading ~20° less than the paraglider's and at roughly three times the paraglider's speed. The traffic rules prohibit a slope-soaring glider from overtaking another aircraft at approximately the same altitude on the ridge.
  5. Right turn back across path: Immediately after overtaking, the glider began a right turn — away from the slope and toward the paraglider's position — most likely to start another figure-eight. The glider pilot had probably already lost visual contact with the paraglider before initiating the turn; with the slope on his left, the low height above terrain and the paraglider on his right, there was no remaining evasive room.
  6. Wing strikes lines; glider spins: The right wing of the glider contacted the paraglider's lines, leaving blue-green, yellow-green and red friction marks on the leading edge. The one-sided drag yawed the glider into a rotation around its vertical axis, similar to a spin. The collision occurred at ~140 m AGL, which left no margin to recover into level flight away from the slope; the aft centre of gravity made the recovery more demanding still.
  7. Both pilots fatally injured: The glider impacted the slope in a near-horizontal, rotating attitude and was destroyed; the pilot was killed on impact. The paraglider, partly collapsed into a heart shape, descended with its unconscious pilot at a survivable rate; he came to rest head-down on a steep slope and died of positional asphyxia before rescuers could reach him. Two rescue helicopters arrived 23 and 30 minutes after the collision.
Loading incidents...
Select Incident
Select Report
Filter
0/0
Incident year
1997 2024
Sort By
Search
0/0
Preferences
Save preferences locally
Enable map view
Language
Theme
About

gliderincidents.com gathers and lists soaring incident reports from official sources. The sources are indicated and linked. These reports are amended by summaries, metadata and translations, some of which have been generated utilizing machine learning (AI). You shouldn't trust the information provided here blindly, and consider reading the official incident report as a fact-check.

OR AND
Flight Phase
Circumstance
Severity Levels
Countries

Please describe what information is incorrect or needs review:

Bookmarked