ASK 18 student solo: stall on slip exit in final approach
An ASK 18 student on a 4th solo of the day at Essen/Mülheim was established in a slip on final when attempting to change direction or recover; nose came too high on slip exit, the glider stalled, dropped off right, and spun at low altitude into a parking lot ~400 m short of the airfield. Student: 20 h total / 34 starts on type; the slip exercise had been signed off as 'mastered' less than a month earlier. The solo order was issued without a current dual check despite a multi-day pause; training records were incomplete across 8 instructors. Glider destroyed; student fatal.
- Winch launch and circuit: 4th solo of the day on ASK 18. Winch launch from Essen/Mülheim rwy 24; downwind, base, and altitudes on pattern observed correct by the supervising instructor from the ground. CAVOK, 270° at 4 kt, 16 °C.
- Limited consolidation on type: Student training began Apr 2017; A-Prüfung Sep 2017, B-Prüfung Apr 2018. Converted to ASK 18 in Sep 2017 after only 3 solos on ASK 21. Total experience 20:17 h / 197 starts; 34 starts on ASK 18 total. BFU notes that 3 solos on the previous type is insufficient consolidation before single-seat conversion; no clear national standards exist for type-conversion timing.
- Solo authorized without dual check: Slip exercise (2.7) signed off as 'beherrscht' only on 2 Sep 2018, less than a month before the accident. After a multi-day flying pause, the solo flight order was issued without a current dual check. BFU contributing-factor finding: a dual check should have happened before the solo order. Training records: 8 instructors involved over the training course; documentation incomplete and not used for progress tracking.
- Low-altitude slip exercise zone: Per DAeC methodology, the slip exercise must end by 50 m AGL — a low-safety-margin exercise that requires careful pre-authorization risk assessment under the operator's SMS. BFU found the ATO's SMS was nominal only.
- Slip exit error in final approach: Witness observation: a stable slip was established in the end part of final, then the student attempted to change the slip direction or exit; on slip exit the nose came too high. BFU notes both scenarios (slip exit vs slip direction change) lead to the same stalled state and treats them as equivalent triggers.
- Stall and spin entry: Aircraft stalled, dropped off to the right, and entered a spin-like rotation at very low altitude before disappearing behind trees.
- Parking lot impact - fatal: Near-vertical impact in a parking lot ~400 m east of (short of) the airfield. Fuselage front buckled upward, tail section broken, rudder separated. Glider destroyed; student sustained fatal injuries (polytrauma). No technical defects; no health impairment.