Arcus M stall in mountain hang turn — terrain collision

Chistehorn, Switzerland Schempp-Hirth Arcus M

After a stall during mountain hang turns about 1 km southeast of Chistehorn at 2,126 m MSL, both pilots of an Arcus M were fatally injured and the aircraft destroyed. After 2.5 hours on day one of a planned cross-country tour from Birrfeld, the glider had been flying figure-8 hang turns along the Rhone ridge for about 12 minutes. A right turn was not completed in sinking air; the critical angle of attack was exceeded and the glider stalled into a steep spiral, striking the rising terrain. A possibly aft CG and unclear two-pilot role-sharing were noted as contributing factors.

  1. Mountain ridge soaring: On day one of a planned two-day Wandersegelflug (Birrfeld → Grenoble → Langenthal), the Arcus M was ridge-soaring at the Chistehorn for about 12 minutes, flying figure-8 hang turns with the half-circles turning away from the slope (recommended technique).
  2. Limited mountain hang-flying time: Pilot A (front, age 46): 1377h total but only 6:10h on the Arcus M across 3 flights. Pilot B (back, age 72): 441h total, of which 46:16h on the Arcus M — but all on flat-terrain cross-country flights in Namibia. Both pilots' mountain hang-flying experience on type was limited.
  3. Possibly aft CG: SUST cites a possibly aft CG as a contributing factor. The rudder-fin tank had 4 L of water (3-L holes taped), placing CG in the mid-to-aft allowable range per AFM. SUST notes that an aft CG accentuates departure behaviour, especially in turning flight.
  4. Two-pilot role-sharing unclear: SUST notes that work-sharing between pilots of different backgrounds can support safety only if pre-flight rules for decision-making and intervention are clearly defined and accepted by both. Whether the two pilots had agreed on roles remains open.
  5. Critical AoA exceeded in turn: At 15:52:58 a right turn was initiated in sinking air; IAS dropped 25 km/h in 15 seconds while the glider gained ~10 m height. SUST analysis indicates the critical angle of attack was exceeded as the aircraft was pulled up in sinking air during the turn.
  6. Stall, steep spiral into terrain: At about 15:53:07 the airflow separated. The aircraft continued turning toward the steeply rising slope and descended at ~23 m/s from ~200 m AGL. Pilot B's hand was found on the flap lever — possibly an attempt to recover from incipient spin by switching to negative camber per the AFM emergency procedure — but altitude was insufficient.
  7. Terrain collision at 2126 m/MSL: The Arcus M collided with the ground in a near-vertical steep spiral at 2126 m/MSL, approximately 1 km southeast of the Chistehorn. Both pilots were fatally injured (polytrauma, instant); the aircraft was destroyed. ELT activated. SUST renews safety recommendation #409 (mandatory stall warning systems on sailplanes) and adds #557 (community sensitization on LOC-I in hang flying).
Loading incidents...
Select Incident
Select Report
Filter
0/0
Incident year
1997 2024
Sort By
Search
0/0
Preferences
Save preferences locally
Enable map view
Language
Theme
About

gliderincidents.com gathers and lists soaring incident reports from official sources. The sources are indicated and linked. These reports are amended by summaries, metadata and translations, some of which have been generated utilizing machine learning (AI). You shouldn't trust the information provided here blindly, and consider reading the official incident report as a fact-check.

OR AND
Flight Phase
Circumstance
Severity Levels
Countries

Please describe what information is incorrect or needs review:

Bookmarked